Tuesday, August 16, 2011

City Living in the Apocalype

2-50-75-80, Carlo Ratti's newest 4 letter word. It describes cities today, that 2% of the Earth's crust, hold 50% of the earth's population, with 75% of energy consumption and 80% of carbon emissions. Chris Lineberger's favorite quote, that people are voting with their feet, to prioritize cities as the new zeitgeist and paradigm of preferred standard of living. In America atleast. In Mumbai, 50% population (5 million +people) come from rural areas out of monetary pressure from impeding development and severe effects of climate change on their food production. Voting is one way to describe it, you could also call the flock to cities a survival tactic. Look at workers housing in china, look in any developing country and you will see the same. I am not yet disenchanted with cities, but am growing more suspicious of their claim to sustainability.

I'm feeling the pressure of the media, the stock market, and the apocalypse. Yes, after hearing an advertisement for Betterment.com, I thought about putting my net worth (which is heavily in the red due to student loans) into a Boston based internet micro-investment fund. I then thought about withdrawing all of my money from the bank, and literally socking it away. Among other doubts in my advocacy for urban life, I read this morning about the 8% fare hike over the next few years in the UK rail system. This reminded me of my buddy's comment last week: it is as expensive for him to drive to work as it is to take the train, with little value add at the train's defense.

So if my brother and friends' 401k's are getting eaten 15% at a time, and it costs as much to drive as it does to take the metro, what stability does DC urban life offer to its main population: idealistic 20 somethings? The apocalyptic teem of my RSS is difficult to ignore. Thanks to Ed Glaeser's most recent release, urban farming has now been negated as a sustainable practice for thriving cities. So if my cohort and the 13% unemployed population cannot retain its savings because of market instability and high cost of living, can't sustainably grow its own food, and are dependent on ever-undependable supply chains (due to climate effects on resources and production), how sustainable is this urban thing anyway?

The Kalahari Bushmen operate under natural limits to growth. They are spaced approximately 200 miles apart with a steady tribe size of 18 people. Since the agricultural revolution, we as a culture have been fighting these natural limits, negating a direct relationship to our natural environment. Given that this has made room for intense cultural exploration and intellectual expansion, we stand by. People voted with their feet during the great suburban expansion of the 1940's- 90's... and now my generation is voting against that. Will the urban promise be as disappointing as the baby boomers' American dream?